Monster Toes Nutter Butters – Perfect For Halloween Entertaining!

by Valerie Gray, From Val's Kitchen

Some posts on this site contain an affiliate link. Clicking on an affiliate link does not increase the cost of the product if you buy it. It does mean that I MAY make a commission if you purchase the item. Affiliate links are used in an attempt to offset the operational costs incurred by running this website. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Need some treats for Halloween entertaining? Monster Toes Nutter Butters are super cute and colorful, and scarily easy to make!

Monster Toes Nutter Butters

Need an easy-to-make treat that screams Halloween? (See what I did there? LOL). Monster Toes Nutter Butters are perfect for Halloween entertaining! These bite-sized treats require no baking at all, just some melting and assembling. They’re so easy to make it’s almost scary. These Monster Toes are super cute and super colorful. Unwrapped Starburst candies and Mike & Ikes make for great toenails. Sprees make terrific eyes. These treats are sure to bring a smile to the faces of children and adults alike. Here’s instructions on how to make Monster Toes Nutter Butters.

Monster Toes Nutter Butters

Equipment Needed

Some of the posts on this site, like this one, contain an affiliate link. Clicking on an affiliate link does not increase the cost of the product for you if you buy it. It does mean that I MAY make a SMALL commission if you purchase the item. Affiliate links are used in an attempt to offset the operational costs incurred by running this website.

Ingredients

  • Nutter Butter cookies (1 for each treat you want to make)
  • candy melts in assorted colors
  • sprinkles (or jimmies if you prefer to call them that) in coordinating colors
  • assorted candies – Starburst, Spree, Mike & Ike

Monster Toes Nutter Butters

Instructions

Line a baking sheet with wax paper. (This helps ensure that the cookies are sticking to a pan or tray.)

Melt the candy melts according to instructions on the package, taking special care not to overheat the candy. If the candy coating is overheated, it will be too thick. You can add 1 teaspoon of coconut oil or vegetable shortening to help thin the candy but do not add any other type of liquid as the candy will seize and harden.

Dip each cookie into the candy melts, making sure to completely coat the cookie.

Gently shake each cookie to remove excess candy, and then place onto the wax paper.

Immediately add the candy to create the “toe” and dust with coordinating sprinkles.

Allow the candy coating to harden before serving.

Should there be any remaining cookies (and that’s unlikely), store them in an airtight container at room temperature. Placing in the refrigerator may cause the cookie to soften.

Monster Toes Nutter Buttersq

If you’re looking for some other recipes for Halloween, be sure to check these out!

You may also like

8 comments

Ms Pretty L Things aka Amanda October 15, 2019 - 12:20 pm

I love the idea of these treats for Halloween.Super easy to make and can be whipped up pretty easy if the kids in the house eat all the other treats!

Reply
MELANIE EDJOURIAN October 15, 2019 - 3:32 pm

These sound like a great little Halloween treat for the kids and trick or treaters. My kids would love making them although I doubt they would leave any for anyone else.

Reply
Rebecca Smith October 15, 2019 - 4:19 pm

Oh what a fun Halloween treat! They’re so colourful and sound so delicious! I love making Halloween goodies with the kids.

Reply
Jennifer October 15, 2019 - 4:58 pm

So colourful! Looks like the perfect treat for Halloween although I doubt they’d last long!

Reply
Sarah Bailey October 15, 2019 - 6:44 pm

Oh my gosh these look like so much fun and sound delicious. I can definitely see myself making some as a Halloween treat!

Reply
WhatLauraLoves October 16, 2019 - 11:50 am

AMAZING!! Thank you so much for this post. We’re having friends over with their kids on halloween before the theatre and these would be perfect for me to make, xxx

Reply
Afshan Nasim October 16, 2019 - 7:42 pm

Those cookies look awesome and yummy. All ready to eat them. They make a fun twist to Halloween ?

Reply
Elizabeth October 17, 2019 - 11:08 am

My sweetie mad son would LOVE these! Such a clever idea! Thanks for the recipe!

Reply

Leave a Comment